Water And Ice Safety: read this before you go
Home › Massachusetts Legends
Massachusetts Legends: 15 stories people tell across 8 regions, each with what the named sources say is actually documented. Vote believe it or no way, then see the answer, and collect them all. The stories are for fun; the facts are sourced.

- 15Stories with named sources
- 8Regions, Berkshires to the islands
- 45Sources, linked on each page
- Oct 31Checked, 2026
- Berkshires
- Central Massachusetts
- Greater Boston
- North of Boston
- South Shore
- South Coast
- Cape Cod
- Islands
- How We Choose
- Looked For
- FAQ
Berkshires
Central Massachusetts
- Johnny Appleseed and the Tin Pot HatLeominster, Worcester County. Legend.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Partly TrueA real man, a shrewd one, and a hat the sources argue over.
- The Four Towns Under the QuabbinQuabbin Reservoir and the Swift River Valley, Franklin, Hampshire and Worcester Counties. History.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Partly TrueReal towns, real losses, and no streets left under the water.
Greater Boston
- The Boston Tea Party and the 'Indian' DisguisesGriffin's Wharf, Boston, Suffolk County. History.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Partly TrueThe tea is certain. The headcount depends on who you ask.
- Paul Revere's Midnight RideBoston, Charlestown, Lexington and Lincoln, Suffolk and Middlesex Counties. Legend.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Partly TrueHe rode. The poem just got the details wrong.
- Bunker Hill and the 'Whites of Their Eyes'Charlestown, Boston, Suffolk County. Legend.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Good Story, Thin ProofThe hill name is off, and the famous order may be too.
North of Boston
- The Salem Witch Trials and Proctor's LedgeSalem, with the Proctor's Ledge memorial at the base of Gallows Hill, Essex County. History.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Told, Not JudgedWe are not rating this one. We are listening.
- The Gloucester Sea Serpent of 1817Gloucester Harbor, Cape Ann, Essex County. Legend.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Tall Tale (We Love It Anyway)The baby serpent was a bent black snake. The big one is still open.
- Dogtown, the Abandoned Village of Cape AnnDogtown Common, Gloucester and Rockport, Essex County. History.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Probably TrueEighty houses, then six, then none, all on the record.
South Shore
- Plymouth RockPlymouth waterfront, Plymouth County. Legend.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Good Story, Thin ProofNo rock in Bradford’s own account, just a memory from 1741.
- The 1621 Harvest Feast and the First Thanksgiving StoryPlymouth, and the Wampanoag homeland, Plymouth County. History.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Told, Not JudgedTwo true things at once, so we do not grade it.
South Coast
Cape Cod
Islands
- The Whaleship Essex and the WhaleNantucket, and the Pacific Ocean, Nantucket County. History.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Probably TrueA documented loss at sea, told plainly.
- Moshup and the Aquinnah CliffsAquinnah (Gay Head) Cliffs, Martha's Vineyard, Dukes County. Tradition.The editors’ take opens with the answer.Told, Not JudgedThe Tribe’s own tradition, so we do not rate it.
How Our Editors Rate These
Once you open a legend, you will find a short take from us. It is opinion about the story, built only from the facts on that page, never new facts. The chip shows where we land:
- Probably TrueThe sources back the main claim.
- Partly TrueSome of it holds up and some of it does not.
- Good Story, Thin ProofPeople tell it, but we found no solid record.
- Tall Tale (We Love It Anyway)The sources say it is not so, and we still enjoy it.
- Told, Not JudgedA sensitive story, so we only note what the sources record.
How We Choose
A story is listed only if at least one named source covers it: a state or federal agency, an archive, a university, a museum, Mass Moments from Mass Humanities, or a named newspaper. We tell the story, then say what is documented and what is not. Paranormal claims are always given as “according to” a named source. Every legend belongs to a real public place, never a private home. A living people’s tradition appears only as that Tribe itself publishes it, with no vote, and we point visitors to the Tribe’s own rules for the land. Salem is told as documented history only. No story that blames a victim, and none about a private person.
Looked for and Not Found
We searched for these and found no source we could name, so they are not on the trail:
- mass.gov pages on the Salem trials and the Proctor's Ledge memorial (access denied)
- Peabody Essex Museum and Phillips Library pages on Salem
- Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe page telling the 1621 story
- Any City of Boston or Freedom Trail statement on Mother Goose
- masshist.org page on the 'whites of their eyes' attribution; Bunker Hill Museum page
- Whydah Pirate Museum official site at whydah.com (domain would not resolve; discoverpirates.com used)
- A City of Gloucester or Essex National Heritage page on the Babson Boulder Trail (not found)
- Great Barrington 1886 (dropped)IEEE ETHW says the plaque calls it the 'first practical system' for AC lighting, built on Gaulard and Gibbs' earlier work, which shows the 'first' claim is qualified. No mass.gov or Smithsonian page was read. Edison Tech Center also read but is a private site.
- Bridgewater TriangleNo primary-source documentation of paranormal claims. A mass.gov article (seen in search, would not open) is said to describe it as folklore and a hotspot tale; search found only environmental designation records (Hockomock Swamp ACEC) and a student paper. Left out of the trail.
- Lizzie BordenThe Fall River Historical Society page we read (Lizzie Andrew Borden and the Paranormal) says the only paranormal material in its archive is letters from mediums to the prosecutor in 1892 and 1893, and the author doubts the claims. No documentation that supports any haunting. Left out; it is a real family murder with named victims.
- Bash Bish Falls Native maiden legendNo tribe-published source found. Search showed mass.gov describing the falls as sacred to Mohican and Scaghticoke peoples (page would not open) and a Stockbridge-Munsee link; nothing connecting a maiden story to any tribal site. Leave out.
- Mother Goose's grave at the Granary Burying Ground in Boston: the only page we could read that tells it is a secondary one, so it is not on the trail
- Lord Timothy Dexter of Newburyport and the warming-pans story: no readable primary or well-documented page, so it is not on the trail
- Skipper Ireson's ride in MarbleheadOnly one secondary source would load, so it is not on the trail
- The Great Molasses Flood of 1919A real disaster with named victims, some of them children, so we leave it off a just-for-fun trail; it is on the history timeline
Keep Exploring
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Massachusetts legends true?
Some have a documented core and some do not. Each page tells the story first and then lists what named sources confirm.
Does my vote count anywhere?
Votes and your collected set stay in your own browser. We do not store or share them.
Can I visit the places?
Each legend page names a real public place that belongs to it and links to its official page. Stay on public paths and follow posted rules; we do not point to private land.
Still Unconfirmed
- Longfellow's poem date (1861): not stated on any page we read; the Paul Revere House says only that it was written 42 years after Revere died.
- Mashpee Wampanoag claim that the Wampanoag arrived uninvited after hearing gunfire: seen only in news summaries.
- Boston Athenaeum photo record of the Mary Goose stone (inscription Mary Goose, wife of Isaac Goose, aged 42): page would not load.
- Boston Tea Party Ships and Museum home page: not read directly; only its Disguise page was read.
- Pilgrim Hall's 1775 versus 1832 first printed reference for the landing tradition: the page does not resolve it; not used.
- Ireson: facts from the Marblehead Current (a newspaper column by a former Marblehead Museum director) were read, but no allowed primary source was read.
- IEEE ETHW milestone page for Great Barrington (read, but IEEE is not on the allowed list and only one allowed-type source was available): March 6 and March 20, 1886, 'first practical' wording. Dropped.
Sources
- Mass Moments (Mass Humanities), Jury Finds Mary Parsons Not Guilty of Witchcraft
- University of Virginia, Salem Witch Trials Documentary Archive, Gallows Hill Project
- Massachusetts Legislature, Acts of 2001 Chapter 122, An Act Relative to the Witchcraft Trial of 1692
- Destination Salem (official Salem visitor bureau), Proctor's Ledge Memorial
- Pilgrim Hall Museum, History of Plymouth Rock
- Pilgrim Hall Museum, Plymouth Rock and Pilgrim Myths
- Pilgrim Hall Museum, The 'First Thanksgiving'
- Plimoth Patuxet Museums, Eye-Witness Account of the 1621 Harvest Celebration
- National Archives, President Abraham Lincoln's Thanksgiving Day Proclamation
- National Park Service, Lincoln Home, Lincoln and Thanksgiving
- Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe, National Day of Mourning (event page)
- National Park Service, Boston Tea Party Timeline
- Massachusetts Historical Society, The Boston Tea Party
- Massachusetts Historical Society, Letter from John Andrews to William Barrell, December 18, 1773
- Boston Tea Party Ships and Museum (secondary source), Disguise of Sons of Liberty
- Library of Congress, Law Library blog, The 250th Anniversary of the Boston Tea Party
- Paul Revere House, Paul Revere's Midnight Rides
- Paul Revere House, The Midnight Ride in Paul Revere's Own Words
- Massachusetts Historical Society, Collections Online, Letter from Paul Revere to Jeremy Belknap
- National Park Service, Minute Man National Historical Park, Paul Revere Capture Site
- National Park Service, The Battle of Bunker Hill
- National Park Service, Colonel William Prescott: A Glorious Immortality
- National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park getaway article
- Massachusetts Historical Society, Object of the Month: An early daguerreotype of Dighton Rock (March 2011)
- Massachusetts Historical Society, Collections Online: Seth Eastman on Dighton Rock
- National Park Service NPGallery, National Register record: Dighton Rock
- Massachusetts Historical Society, The Beehive: The Missing Whydah Treasure (June 2020)
- Mass Moments, October 30, 1985: Whydah identified
- Whydah Pirate Museum, About Us
- Massachusetts Historical Society, The Beehive: It appeared so strange and wonderful (October 2019)
- Cape Ann Museum, Trails and Sails: Celebrate the Gloucester Sea Serpent
- City of Gloucester, Dogtown Cellar Holes
- City of Gloucester, Dogtown: Government Involvement
- Cape Ann Museum, Walking Tour: Historic Dogtown, A Walk Back in Time
- Mass Moments, November 20, 1820: Whaleship Essex sinks
- Nantucket Historical Association, Essex exhibit: A Dreadful Calamity
- Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah), Ancient Ways
- Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah), Wampanoag History
- City of Leominster, Previous Leominster Legends (John Chapman entry)
- Mass Moments (Mass Humanities), 'Johnny Appleseed' Dies
- North Carolina Historic Sites, John Chapman: Pioneer Nurseryman
- Mass Moments (Mass Humanities), Quabbin Reservoir Filled to the Brim
- Swift River Valley Historical Society, Swift River Museum (resources page)
- Mass Moments (Mass Humanities), Workers Complete Hoosac Tunnel
- American Society of Civil Engineers, Hoosac Tunnel (Historic Landmark page)
Read on October 31, 2026. How we check: editorial standards; spot a mistake? tell us.
Cite this page: It's Massachusetts, “Massachusetts Legends”, itsmassachusetts.com/legends/ (updated ). By the It's Massachusetts editorial team. Free to quote with attribution and a link to this page; data and tables are licensed CC BY 4.0.